Anytown Advancing - Powered by Full Frame Initiative

By ABCD Community Development, the City of Springfield, and Full Frame Initiative     |    November 21, 2023

The City of Springfield is planning to build a new library branch and recreation center complex at St. Johns Park. In October and November 2023, we surveyed neighbors who live within a half mile of the site to learn about how they felt this project might impact various aspects of their wellbeing. Why wellbeing?

The survey explored the proposed project’s impact on five aspects of wellbeing. While a majority of residents expected the project to improve their wellbeing, they also named a variety of tradeoffs related to the project that we explore further below.

We invite you to explore the data and learn more below:

Who we surveyed

Our data collection efforts focused on gathering data from residents who were under-sampled in previous surveys, including Black or African-American residents, Hispanic or Latino residents, youth and elder (60+ year old) residents, and residents with household incomes less than $50k. Here’s a picture of who filled out our surveys:

Race/Ethnicity

We were successful in prioritizing collecting input from:

  • Black or African-American residents
  • Hispanic or Latino residents

How will this project will impact the community's wellbeing?

What residents told us

Data Highlights

Areas to Celebrate

Very positive responses overall across most questions

  • 88% agree with the Mayor’s vision
  • 78% said overall positive impact on wellbeing, highest for social connectedness + access to relevant resources
  • No demographic group had a >10% negative rating on any of the five domains of wellbeing
  • Most areas had general alignment between demographic groups
Areas to Explore

Suggested areas to pay attention to in the comments

  • Safety had the lowest ratings (although still overall positive), particularly for residents who are Black, low income, and/or young
  • Female residents generally rated questions ~10% higher than males
  • More neutral ratings on stability and mastery

Explore the Data

How will this project impact your wellbeing?   

What residents told us

Comments in open-ended questions

Showing $P1 responses to this question
Filtered to show $P1 out of $P2 responses to this question

Community Voices

Choose a survey question

Display

Search for text

Race/Ethnicity

Gender

Age Category

Household Income

If you said that this project would positively affect you in some ways, please share why.

If you said that this project would negatively affect you in some ways, please share why.

Thinking about what you're concerned about losing, or other negatives, what would make this project more worth it to you?

Is there anything you'd like to explain about the ratings you chose?

Is there anything else you want to share about the project, or about you?

warning
It looks your filters resulted in only a few responses. We generally recommend reviewing at least 30 comments if you want to consider the viewpoints expressed here as representative. You can broaden your search by removing some of the filters you've selected.
warning
Sorry, we couldn't find anything that matches your criteria. Please broaden your search by removing some of the filters you've selected.
I feel that any projects that positively impact Cleveland, is a plus for the people that live here!
I really don't have any negative concerns!
I hope this project happens. It would most definitely be good for Cleveland!!
Let's get this project started!!
Won't affect me at all
Won't affect Me at All
If you really do what you say you're going to do because we all know they never do.
Stop the bullshit.
I will have some where affordable to hang out
More traffic, Over priced dining and activities Little accommodations for disabled people
I think that he invested in the waterfront it's good for in northeast Ohio
another great resource to the waterfront besides edgewater. And a great use of land/Soave instead of driving by and seeing nothingness and decay.
I would be concerned that gentrification and discrimination would occur that would gatekeep acres to all.
Give Cleveland a positive image of repurposing and sustainability fir land use /buildings that have sat unused/vacant.
Get something done beyond just talking it to death. Execute.
This project would positively affect my life, because it will give me opportunities to enjoy affordable recreation, nature, physical, and spiritual activities, and more.
This project would also be worth it to me if affordable housing was built near the lakefront. In many cities, only the wealthy have access to the lakefront or the environment is unwelcoming to people of lower economic status.
Having spent time in Chicago, where multiple communities come together and share in their lakefront, I believe that this will bridge the divide between bringing together Clevelanders of racial, cultural, and socioeconomic differences. My statements above, reflect the fact that I travel out of the state and country, in order to have a better quality of life.
There should be facilities so that the lake is accessible throughout the four seasons.
Nada
Esto va a causar más tráfico en downtown, más problemas con seguridad, y va costar mucho dinero eventualmente a los que son dueños de casa porque dicen que ellos tienen dinero ahora para hacer el proyecto pero y luego para mantenerlo?
Que hubiera más detalles sobre cuáles son los verdaderos planes, las verdaderos beneficios, y los verdaderos no beneficios.
Buena suerte
No ciments
No ciments
No cime ts
No c0ments
* Tener espacios para la familia es grandioso. Te hace sentir vivo. * Compartir con los amigos. * Ver la ciudad limpia, organizada, te da una sensación de INCLUSIÓN y deseos de pertenecer. * sentirse orgullosos de nuestra amada ciudad "Our Land"
Nada que perder, debemos seguir superando como ciudad, aunque tengamos que sacrificar otros aspectos.
El español es poco comprensible en la encuesta.
Let's do it. - Vamos a lograr este proyecto por nuestra gente, nuestra ciudad para beneficio de todos. Hagamos que Cliven vuelva a brillar y que podamos sentirnos más orgullosos de nuestra ciudad.
Lugares adicionales para el disfrute del lago y realizar deportes acuáticos.
El desarrollo y la amplitud de infraestructura es siempre para desarrollo económico más amplio.
I we have a beautiful waterfront and I think we should use it as much as possible.
I don't live in Cleveland now, but I was born and raised in Cleveland. I love my city!
I feel that this will allow more opportunities for community events and safe areas for families to enjoy what Cleveland has to offer.
It won't negatively affect me at all.
Seeing different groups of people in our city be able to use the lakefront for their own peace and leisure.
Hope to see this project come alive!
More entertaining & fun for the residents & more revenue for the city & businesses.
If this project can generate revenue & it can be used to help the community.
No comments
No comments
There are currently no parks or decent family areas in my neighborhood, I have to drive out to other cities to experience nature.
Keeping the residents of the east in mind with this project, it seems like the eastsiders of Cleveland are always left out!
Cleveland has never had a mental spaces,, we need them.
Please consider our elderly residents and how accessible the park would be to them.
I would hate for the people who live here to benefit from the money and opportunities.
See Clevelanders hired and have an invested into the buy-in. Possible Equity in the property where they can have a say.
I would love to see pictures of people that reflect the demographic of Cleveland the monitories, Their culture and hire artist that can deliver. Get the schools involved.
I am an Occupational Therapist and I am passionate about my family and city. I plan to grow old here.
This project would give access to the waterfront where I can take my family and enjoy a day either out in the water or seeing the sites like the park in Lakewood which is further away than Cleveland is for us
Developing this plan will not make my everyday life any better or worse however it would add something fun and exciting to do during the summer months sigh friends & family
I need to look more into this.
It'll help with mental health by providing peace and tranquility.
Give the locals more things to do in Cleveland.
Having stuff for everyone.
I hope the project benefits everyone .
already mentioned above
thing might get too expensive and not for the local
You can always find positives in everything.
How much will this cost the citizens.
If it doesn't burden the pockets of the residents.
Some I didn't understand
This young lady said this project will be covered by federal project money the city will get, but what happens once that money is gone? Who pays for the maintenance, safety, and everything that goes into keeping up with it?
The positives are because it can benefit the city's downtown residents and people that work there. It can help bring visitors into our city.
It won't help everyone in the city. This will be more for the downtown people and visitors, neglecting the needs of other residents and neighborhoods.
This is not bad, but shouldn't be priority over other city needs.
This can go both ways.
No a la inclusión
Paz y amor
A new place in Cleveland to visit
It wont
Something new to do with family.
No fees or hidden costs to gain access.
Love having more places to hang out with family and friends
I can breathe fresh air and feel calm.
Having festivals for the community or giveaways, to ensure inclusivity.
I wanna place that I can feel safe and there is security person now to be on Watch. I want to be calm.
I believe this is an awesome opportunity to create some peace in our city, and a unified city is makes strong community.
This would be another great place to visit, and spend time winding down or decompressing. Nature helps me decompress.
Inclusivity Safety Access Cleanliness Maintenance
Excited to see how this turns out. I'd like to have another place to visit, spend time, show off and take outsiders to when they visit.
More access to nature.
Keeping the stadium there takes up valuable space Cleveland could use to better access the lake
concerned with losing the public's right to build, manage, and control this space because we've leased so much of it to the billionaires who own the Browns, like we've done with the riverfront.
very important the city retain ownership and control over this space. I could be so wonderful!
I feel really good about the city of Cleveland and where it's going.
I'm only looking at the positives.
Involve the community
Being able to casually access the lake would allow me to meet with friends and family in a space that is safe, close to nature and calming.
Gentrification. I don't want to be pushed out by people not native to the community who can push the prices of houses up, and cause landlords to sell our houses to developers.
Creating programs to specifically enhance / give more opportunities to the current people of the community to enjoy and utilize these spaces
Lived in the inner city of Cleveland my whole life
Seria una Buena mejora Para Los habitantes
El acceso facil
Parking should be free for locals
It will make me feel better about my city and what it has to offer.
I love being a outside so if there are trails in green space, then I'll enjoy that.
I don't think it is close enough to me for it to make a huge difference in my daily life, but I would go there 5-6 times a year. There may also be opportunities for my classroom.
I hope Mayor Bibb remembers to listen to the voice of his voters. The people of Cleveland want more opportunities and they/we deserve a mayor that will provide better.
We'll be able to include the waterfront as a regular part of daily and seasonal activities, which was very limited before.
I think it's time Cleveland utilized the waterfront as a place to build community and as a nice amenity that other cities would be lucky to have.
I love places to walk around and look at petty things so that would make me happy
I think this will be a fun recreation spot for me but I don't think it will change most of my day to day
Everyone should feels as if opportunity is endless & can create a healthy mind space , develop and increase a positive vision no matter the circumstances that surround them!!
Giving someone the opportunity to relax with family in an outdoor open environment will create more peace & great self awareness!!
If the vision is truly for the people!!
I know in life …In order to get what you want you must grind & put the work in to create the life you desire … I also feel that nature & water are healing properties that everyone can use to increase health & lifestyle !!!
Life in the city that I call home would be more full and complete if the downtown lakefront was a part of the fabric of city like.
I'm not a robot.
It will make our waterfront much more accessible. That is wonderful!
I don't see how the project would negatively impact anyone except by reallocating resources away from other programs/projects. It is essentially adding better public space to an amenity.
I cannot see how what is essentially a real estate project would have much impact on the things listed above.
I think the project is wonderful and I hope it gets built. Lake access from downtown is much-needed. Don't forget that this project will only be successful if people want to get there and can get there. There is still a large highway separating the site from downtown. The land bridge would be great to improve that access but bus access is still limited around there. It is great to have access with a functioning RTA Waterfront Line but most Clevelanders don't have easy access to the RTA rail network.
This would make the lakefront more accessible for me. I don't visit as often as i like because of the hassle to get there. Also because there isn't much recreation. This project can fix that by making it more community involved.
The only worry i have is about safety for everyone. Security could be a good resource, but sometimes they pose more of a threat than protection. They could hire lifeguards/ patrol to fix this.
Safe green space/walking areas can have a positive impact on a communities mental health
The city needs to do what I can to make one continuous lakefront trail from Lakewood to Euclid.
One of my favorite things about the Cleveland area is the access to the lake. It's the closest thing to a beach that we have and needs to be protected as a nature site. Whenever I see the lake and the lakeside parks bustling with people who love the lake too, I get so happy and grateful to be in a city that has such a nice a space that many other cities don't have.
Nature is healing and Cleveland has the wonderful luck of being situated so close to a Great Lake. We must take advantage of that.
I love Cleveland. And although I'm from Avon (one county over & about 33 min from downtown), I consider Cleveland my home city and only want it to improve.
It would help make me more proud to live in Cleveland. I am always looking for things to do outside too.
Ample, free parking! I often avoid going downtown merely because parking is a hassle or expensive.
if it isnt racialiy driven then it would be good
it depeneds on the atmosphere
it being 100 percent for everyone
I like sitting by the water. It's relaxing and peaceful.
Crime. I'm concerned about safety,
Let's make Cleveland great again. Reduce the crime.
No I'm okay
it would affect me by helping me learn.
it wouldn't negatively affect me.
I'm concerned about helping the people that need it.
There is nothing i would like to share.
I don't have enough info to put together a census agreement
I don't have enough info to put together a census agreement
I don't have enough info to put together a census agreement
I don't have enough info to put together a census agreement
I don't have enough info to put together a census agreement
I've always felt born in the world and I've been wanting to get out of the house. So I think this would help for people I need to get out and go there but also for parents to take their kids so they don't feel like I do.
Maybe make the area more fun and appealing for our young people.
I like this idea and I hope we can make the world and Cleveland a better place for everyone.
A mi no me va afectar necesariamente, porque como te dije ya yo estoy muy viejita, pero esto le puede ser beneficioso a la gente joven que tiene la fuerza para aprovechar todas estas cosas en esta ciudad.
Tienen que pensar que deben de hacer esto para que todos puedan compartir. Para que todos puedan llegar y que no sea muy caro para la gente. Hay familias grandes que no tienen mucho dinero y debe pensar en ellos.
Que dios los bendiga y tengan mucha suerte con este proyecto.
It make me give my visitors a place to go
I don't see any thing negative
It is long overdue do
We need to have a Cleveland cruise line
There's so much history about our city, that needs to be shared.
All good
All good
I want the better for my city and downtown area.
It will improve our city and relationships.
The lake front is becoming more unfriendly to the poor
All just don't include the poor
Some of the questions does not apply too good growth
Better bus service to downtown.
It won't.
Don't know
Make sure there is a project
I can have a place to enjoy fishing
No it would not
More police.
How will I feel safer to fish will there be more policeman
I like to fish all night I want to be comfortable and safe
Nothings
No I do not
Get you out the house
Safety.
If they fix my house.
You someone to listen to you
Somewhere I can take my girl and be safe
Safety I want to enjoy being downtown if I go
Losing money being safe
I would like you to ,are things enjoyable in Cleveland
I would feel like this development will make me feel like I belong here.
I would love for this project to include a hotel if possible for a vaction on the beach feel.
I do love downtown CLE. There are times when it is difficult to get into the Flats. Hopefully, a new development will address that problem.
More like input from the community.
I hope it goes well.
Having a space that is family friendly, easily accessible and open to everyone of all ages would affect Cleveland positively.
Making it affordable. The Aquarium was a good idea, but it is so expensive.
In families with children, price may cause some families to be left out.
It will not positively affect me or my position
We have pressing issues, such as homelessness and crime that are not being addressed.
I feel the mayor is not addressing the needs of the homeless and mental health issues
Yes
Notice that people are in control it can help us understand others control our safety with no worries its a sensitive scheme to do better
To give us a different life style out of life and figure out how to control
It goes to a environmental program
If it helps the process to make a decision on what we can do in any case of happiness
Having a place to go that can help reduce sadness. Having others around you can always be a better thing for everyone.
I think that another place to go and relax will help everyone.
El compartir y pasar el día o un tiempo haciendo ejercicios y caminar ayudaría a muchas cosas. Y que tengan servicio sanitario.
Podría afectar negativamente si van personas indeseadas.
Que tenga buena vigilancia y seguridad.
Sería un mejor lugar para ir a reflexionar, distraerse de los afanes de vida. Suena como una muy buena idea.
Solo que es muy buena idea y buena recreación que es muy importante. Y que sea algo que uno se sienta cómodo y a gusto.
It would give me things to do down there.
Concerned about the trade offs between building this and investing in my neighborhood. I would rather they invest in my neighborhood
I like that it will bring people to cleveland and bring their money
I'm not sure if this project will really make a difference in my personal life but I've been in the city for so long and in this area code that I would love to see things be updated so that my family can enjoy it.
I'm just hoping that this project brings in good people and more tourists so that the city can gain more money. I really hope it does not bring in the riffraff as I live in an area where there are a lot of older people and I don't want to be bothered with extra traffic flow.
No creo que causaría ninguna diferencia como tal.
Si fuera algo más cerca o más conveniente.
Eso va hacer muy retirado como para que uno pueda frecuentarlo. Tal vez de paseo un mal día pero nada que pueda impactar mi día a día.
Seems like it would be a more family-friendly place; a place for tourist/visitors. Quiet places are nice, but lively places (like adding the downtown rink during cold months) are welcomed for a change of pace.
I'd hope that it wouldn't be destroyed by Browns' tailgaters.
I have retired
Will give me an opportunity to enjoy nature, to find a place to relax and reorganize my thoughts whenever I feel overwhelmed or stressed out.
If this project is built thinking of our families and the diversity of cultures and races in our city.
Creating that space will give people a new and better place to relax and enjoy nature
Sería positivo porque tendría otro lugar donde puedo ir a visitar y relajarme.
No creo que me afectaría negativamente.
Tal ves que podamos tener la posibilidad de que los pobres como yo podamos disfrutar de el lugar y las cosas ahí si son con precios razonables.
Bueno yo pienso que aunque es un buen proyecto para la comunidad, no creo que tenga que ver directamente con algunas cosas que mencionaron como mi capacidad de pagar mis cuentas o los recursos que recibí ya que no se como el proyecto tenga que ver con eso.
Por favor piensen en los ancianos.
it would probably be affect us I will be my fiance and my family because I feel getting them nice of the places the mix the mix family is to get a carpooling walking you nice for the front you know it just makes everybody happier and make people think positive and make people want to work together for nationalities black white in Spanish can you spend about different cultures and y'all get to know each other and that's how we feelokay
I feel like this project will help but you need to share off of people cuz he just citizens and people can need help filling out application people care are not more intelligent on the spread the word and show them and help people that need help understanding doesn't make in a better place your eyes and look better houses and look better because financially help with the program Telltale I heard about fixing up places neighborhood about a year ago and they haven't started yet show some improvements and people will jump on the bandwagon I feel get the more houses that will get put together that are turned down or abandoned people will want to live here people will want to move here people were wondering if they have help everybody with do the same follow suit
making everything look better it makes us the community that makes Community makes us feel better and make and give the people more opportunities to exercise and take better they care their stuff and look at people as they're equal n
I would like for them to start having a project to help senior citizens with the new things that they have for getting your house Improvement they have all kind of applications for your roof to get fixed and different stuff to get fixed on your house because like me I'm 66 years old and I've been trying to get some help with my roof for the longest and every time I get an application or something I'm always like I'm not approved it's for something so I feel like we should get a program to go around to houses that need help with senior citizens and have someone to sit down with them with these applications and show them how to go about fixing them and and then but they can be approved to get their house and their yards and stuff looking better for people because I am a senior citizens and I want my house to look better and I'm doing all that I care with a fixed income so I'll see you soon income she's trying they should try to get a program to help them more with their property Ithat way people have the houses looking better and everybody want to help each other and want to live here and have their families grow here and it'll be a better place for everybody
I just feel that there will be no changes to my actual life style aside from having to dish out more money.
The vision board looks nice, but what is the projected outcome?
More things to do
Activities
Safety and motivation security.
Safety and variety for people disabilities
I am on a fixed income. Cost will be a big barrier
As a Cleveland resident, projects that provide near-by enjoyment - accessible by bus and walking - are appreciated. We won't need to waste fuel driving or seeking transportation to go elsewhere.
I can't think of any negatives unless the cost is prohibitive and/or it wastes rather than serves our sustainability goals as a city. I want Cleveland to do its part to help save the planet.
The people who "need" all of us are our aging city population, so resources that are open to, or serve, them allows them to age in place. I hope that the walking access to this project I highlighted will also mean access for wheelchairs.
I've often thought we don't have enough places to enjoy the Lake, especially while dining, so I'm hoping this project includes some affordable sit-down places where you are waited on, rather than fast-food pick-up places.
Thanks
Downtown is already complicated especial on game days. Making this is only going to make things worse. Parking is going to be an arm and leg just to go to the waterfront just because it's downtown. I don't know. This doesn't sound good to me.
Free parking more officers for safety better traffic control
Safety is already bad. It's only going to get worse.
Put the money into something better
An active and accessible waterfront benefits tax payers and that's a plus for all folks.
Any negative answers from above was really about me wanting to be at the Lakefront instead of going to work.
What would excite me about this project is a huge skateboard park. There are teenagers throughout Cleveland that skateboard and there is no place for them to enhance their craft. If we never give them a space they will continue to use other spaces that are not designed for skateboarding.
This project should run the length of the lakefront, not just the Westside
No change
I just don't want or need the city of Cleveland to take away from the most important things to address and put towards Lake Erie instead
No until we the people are able to figure out how to $pend those PB CLE funds in sequence first and foremost, then if it's anything left we can see how to accomplish our Lake Erie goals
Remember, PB CLE funds is to be directed towards most important first and foremost instead of the Lake Erie first
Please more helps for the community
I feel that this project will give me & my family another place to connect & spend time with each other.
I don't think this project will affect me negatively.
I live close to downtown but I don't feel like it will impact my life directly.
Hopefully there will be more things offered to do.
Excelente proyecto
Integrar más a la comunidad hispana en actividades recreativas y productivas
Feliz, Cleveland está más en avanzar a una mejor ciudad
Para el turia.o
It would affect our social lives by giving us something else to do.
The more activities in the more opportunities offered with this project will attract more people to participate and visit.
This is a good idea for a new attraction for people who come to visit Cleveland also.
We want more nice places to go with our family. Particularly our family has a member with accessibility issues and a wheelchair.
Pienso que tiene beneficios para todos. Están pensando en los distintos grupos de edades.
Si cuesta mucho las cosas.
Que sea completamente gratuito y cómodo.
Gracias
Soy puertoriqueño y una de las cosas que me gustaría es sentir que estoy en mi isla, donde tenemos agua por todas partes como en el lago
No. Muchas gracias al mayor por esta iniciativa
Going to a happy place and experience good things of life
Being able to relax and shop and meet new people
That's it's time for everyone to get the depressed mindset out of the picture live our lives in our city at least happy with happy and postive places to go
We need to build Cleveland up more
This project is really amazing. The fact that people are trying to bring the community of Cleveland together is beneficial. Not just the people of Cleveland but possibly other communities that will get inspiration to create something like this. This project is important because there is a lot of human on human violence and to be honest I believe it is pointless, harmful, and unproductive.
What would make it more worth it to me is creating something for kids and teens who are interested in sports to be given the opportunity to have a professional coach and have the peak coaching experience especially because it is near a sports facility that they look up to.
A new place to have fun
If you feel better by getting away from everyday matters everything runs better in your life
More natural scenery
Everyone loves a place to get away from everyday matters. This can help
I have lived here 27 yrs. And in the last few years it is turning worse. We need this
safety resources will that are already depleted will be less
I believe the money can go someplace else more useful.
Cleveland need more building period
Make this project affordable and reasonable so that everybody can enjoy themselves. So may be a nonprofit can fund it
That's about it. I can't wait.
Walking and getting around
Don't know.
Having a job
I love when the community comes together
I love the water it's a place to recharge refocus and I always wanted a restaurant on the water.
Racial and background barriers. There is no real new chance for people with backgrounds only certain people. In my much needed opinion I think things should be a case by case basis.
If I could for sure get a real chance at utilizing some real estate on the waterfront.
Reformation should be taken more seriously we have families and 16 year old barriers shouldn't still be affecting me. How long should a person pay for mistake?
It will make me raising my children more beneficial because of the quality controlled environment.
Just can't wait to see it happen.
I think I'd actually come outside more then I do
I hope they keep residents ideas in front of mind
I do go to festivals and rock 'n' roll hall, and Browns games down there, I would love the added activities.
It is not a negative for me.
I like to propose plan just the way it is.
No, I really love this project, and hope we can move forward. I support this project.
I love the project!
I think it would positively affect me because the more opportunities the better for me and the people I know. I think this will help bring the east and the west of Cleveland together.
I'm a little concerned about how long it will take to actually make this happen.
A better environment
It wouldnt
A better environment
I believe it is a great idea and will have a positive impact giving people a place to go to connect, explore what the city has to offer etc
Honestly I would like More details to adequately answer that.
Most of the questions didn't seem relevant to the project. I don't see where the project would impact me in most of those areas I selected no change.
I have two young boys that need a safe place to play. They enjoy outside and I would love to have somewhere that they enjoy being.
I
Just make it happen
Por la oportunidad de conocer y relacionarse. con otras personas
Nada mas que agregar
Hay que sacar probecho a Los recursos naturales y mas si contribuye con la interaction y recreation Sana
No problem
No me afecta
No me afecta
El tiempo de calidad que puedo pasar en familia, divirtiéndome con ellos.
Me gustaría tener un lugar donde recrearme con mis hijos y familiares. Con actividades de pesca.
Me gustaría tener Centro de creación, tal como Arias para softbol, béisbol, etc.
Y este proyecto puede afectarme positivamente, pero muy poco.
Este proyecto es neutral pienso yo. Yo creo que es algo que puede ser positivo pero solo si uno toma ventaja del lugar y lo que ofrecen.
Me preocupa que este proyecto afecte los impuestos de los propietarios.
Having a place to enjoy nature is always a nice thing
Having a safe place for my family to hang out
It would provide a nice place to visit.
Estoy no me va afectar
No se, tal ves que lo vea desarrollado en realidad y ver cómo le sirve a la comunidad.
Yo no entiendo como se supone que un proyecto en el lago va ayudarme a pagar me las cuentas.
Me gustaría trabajar en este proyecto si es verdad.
I want this money spent in my neighborhood
The mayor only cares about downtown
Que sea una realidad
Eso todo
Ojalá se cumpla el proyecto
De acuerdo
the project will bring more money to the city
may increase cost of living
there will be more work opportunity.
I guess if the project was given more to the people or helping the people progress, that would make me feel a whole lot better
I do not feel that this is going to change my life in any way
It would help me feel better by being outside and if there is space to walk, to get more exercise.
place to go and relax
more kid friendly activities
it will be a nice place to spend with family having a goodtime
to do more stuff with the family
thank you for thinking of the community
Seria Bueno que se Hagan Mas actividades
No me affects
Buena suerte
No me afecta
No me afecta
La calidad de tiempo que podemos pasar en familia, disfrutar tanto del lago, hacer actividades al aire libre.
Me gustaría sentir que mi opinión cuenta en la ciudad y sería de mucho agrado poder acceder caminando a la costa marítima.
Me gustaría que hubieran áreas de recreación para niños y adultos como un gym al aire libre.
Yo pienso que este lugar puede ayudar que muchas cosas cambien para mi y para otros. Puede ayudar mucho en el futuro, y puede cambiar la vida de muchas personas y la economia de nuestra ciudad.
Pienso que ayudaria si tienen atracciones para variedad de edades para que toda la familia pueda disfrutar y aprovechar el lugar
Con Dios delante, espero poder ver este proyecto logrado.
Is gonna be positive because you going to feel good and when you feel good you can do better for many other things.
Make it easy to get there and make it cheap or free.
Put policeman there for we can feel safe when we go because it is downtown.
It would just be another spot of improvement.
No negative affect
Having a new place to visit
It can be a place where you can relax. It can be a place you can share with your family.
I would like to go and hear some live music there often.
This would be great for me and my daughter because we don't do much and she liked the idea and I usually don't see her interested in a lot of stuff.
I like the idea but am afraid that if this happens I won't get something like this closer to me.
I don't feel safe or welcome going down there
If this was to be connected with investment in my neighborhood
I do not feel safe going there. I would be more likely to use it if I feel safe
I don't feel safe walking to metro. I want this type of amenity in my neighborhood. (Stockyard)
I feel like the city does not welcome people like me. I don't feel safe with the police this will not make this safer. If I don't feel safe in my own neighborhood I won't feel safe going downtown
Public restrooms. Downtown can be jerks with people not fom downtown. Need more activities for kids
This would be money invested in the wrong place and things. There is so much more needs in the actual neighborhoods. Children need safer places right in their neighborhood that they can easily get to and use that will provide resources for them. As a parent that works two jobs it would be hard for me to take a trip downtown just for my child to enjoy this place. There's so many things wrong with this.
This would be worth it if we had things already established closer to home that provides resources that are valuable and places that are within reach right in our neighborhood.
I have to keep two jobs to make ends meet, and I don't have the luxury of being able to take my children to many places so for me having resources close to home, would not only benefit me, but also my children who so desperately need it.
The project will unify cleveland
This is going to take money away from where it's really needed. Downtown doesn't need more crap. The neighborhoods do.
We need projects that will directly benefit the residents right where they at.
The residents will carry the burden of this project.
Stop wasting money a bs and do the right thing for the city.
Money is going to be spent on other people not me
If there was a space that I would be welcomed
I don't feel welcome down there
We love the water Increase property value Boost economy
No negatives
I'm excited for it.
A great place for families. A nice new place to eat and shop.
Add a lot of business to Cleveland
Better access to more fun things in life
Security
Fighting anxiety so this may help me
This would be good to get people out of the house.
Good luck
Would help by spending More time with LoVEd ones and getting people who are stuck inside there homes from outdoor recreation and insecurities about safety and will improve even more minds on this project
I feel like this project would positively affect me because It would bring a fresh feeling to the space I live in.
I think more groups of people such as the black and Hispanic population should be considered when making something like this.
I'm a nature person. This location is right downtown so it's a perfect fit between the marina and Edgewater. This project can cross connect with tourists and locals. I'M
I am a musician and I feel as if this will be a great network location along with the many opportunities planned in the future.
I feel the world trying to tear families apart especially black families. This will bring us together
Everything we asking for!
I feel as it
There are very few, public place that equally accessible and enjoyable for people.
No
Because it will make the city worst because of the new tax bracket
No taxes
The women can walk in the walkway with bikini
I feel as though the question aren't truly pertaining to the proposal.
Being listened to about not creating ornamental gardens could create an opportunity for me as an urban farmer that would then change all of the above answers.
I'm concerned about the already existing greenspace and how the biodiversity along the water will be impacted.
This project tho beautiful is not going to directly impact my life unless I am directly involved with making it happen. It may change the city and how I interact with the city but i don't forsee that reaching to the depths of my needs for my family.
Here in Cleveland there are not many open spaces that are nice enough for people of minorities or even children that want to get out the house and see other places and environments but their parents can't afford to take them anywhere or give them a quality experience. In reality the few places that people go to for fun, good eats or shopping are in richer neighborhoods for instance Pincrest, market hall, and Crocker park, lakewood park. All great areas but no all are necessarily welcomed bc of their social status. I will say I understand safety and how certain groups or young teens can sometimes cause chaos. However, Pincrest had rules for kids under 18 and there are always at least 5 police cars along with security patrolling the area for safety, the same thing can be done for the lake front. The lake in general is a local space where all people no matter there background, social status or color like to enjoy a area like that and if the project goes through I think it'll be a great opportunity for smalls businesses a space for fairs and festivals, local activities. Cleveland is known for being a terrible place give the people that live here something to look forward too especially near holidays and weekends and the for the people that don't live here give them something to look forward to when they visit. Market this area not just for the wealthy but for everyone! I could go on and on but you should get the point by now if you would like to here anymore cool ideas that I have I am happy to help.
This is a great idea for a park and it will help not only the youth but families as a whole spend more quality time with each other along with new job openings for people
It would people minds somewhere better , focus on bettering , more opportunities,
This will positively affect me and my community, because it will bring Cleveland out more and bring the community together.
It won't.
They should add next GEN arcade with next GEN consoles where people can walk in and just play.
It would make me feel more relevant and involved.
If there were ppl who were against it ruining the whole activities.
I think it would be worth it
He is not really thinking about the Cleveland people because he spending money a things that are not important for everybody.
Put the money into the recs or school programs. Help the people out more. Fix houses in The neighborhood. Get homes for the homeless people. Those are better ideas to spend the money.
This is a horrible idea
Ease of access to the lakefront and more places to visit
Clevelands crime rate has been escalating but with a nice new public safe and community feeling environment, it can help me feel safe to be out in the city I grew up in
Being able to bring all communities together and not just "surrounding" communities
Si hacen todo eso, pues le beneficiaría a todo el mundo porque pueden compartir y conocer más gente.
No aplica.
Hacer actividades que representen incluyan diferentes razas y nacionalidades.
No, por ahora.
Que traten de considera la gente de varios recursos.
Yo pienso que esto sí sería bueno para mí porque yo puedo salir después del trabajo o algo así y despejar la mente y Relax.
No, esto no me afectaría en ninguna manera.
Y que hagan cosas bonitas para la gente hispana porque siempre hacen cosas para la gente americana.
Este proyecto puede afectarme positivamente porque será un lugar donde puedo ir y compartir con los seres que amo o con personas que son importantes para mi. Puedo ir para mejorar mi salud mental y física.
Tal vez tenga algún efecto negativo, pero no creo que sea significante.
Este proyecto valdría más la pena sí, se pudiera crear un ambiente donde todos quiera ir a visitar, aún los turistas.
Vamos Cleveland! Nosotros podemos!
Bueno sí, podría afectarme positivamente porque mis días libres los paso siempre en mi casa y quisiera un lugar donde pudiera ir a divertirme.
Que sea un lugar seguro. Que tenga diversión para adultos y para niños y que sea económico.
Soy madre soltera y me encantaría que fuera un lugar donde yo pueda llevar mis hijos y que ellos se lo disfruten mucho pero que yo también pueda relajarme mientras que ellos gozan y no tenga que gastar mucho dinero. Porque todo siempre es carísimo.
Pienso que me afectaría positivamente ya que sería algo nuevo para recrearme y distraerme
Pienso que valdría más la pena porque podría aprovechar las diferentes culturas que estarán allí
No por ahora
Pienso que esto atraería más al turismo a nuestra ciudad
Mis hijos y yo venimos de Puerto Rico y estamos impuesto a pasar el tiempo en la playa o en el campo y a veces nos hace falta salir y sentir un poco de eso. Y este lugar nos ayudaría. No es lo mismo pero ayudaría.
Sería bueno que tenga un lugar donde uno pueda montar una hamaca y cocinar con carbón y pasarse un día como si estuviera en la playa allá en Puerto Rico.
Que podamos beber al aire libre como en Puerto Rico.
To help better
It is nice to have somewhere to go where there is water to clear your head. It would be nice to have seating areas with a view of the lake and the city to just sit and relax and enjoy.
Me afectaría positivamente por qué me ayudaría a tener un lugar donde llevar a mis hijos a compartir y salir de la rutina diaria y que puedan aprender a disfrutar y apreciar la naturaleza.
Que tenga bastante cosa para que mis hijos se lo puedan disfrutar, porque me gustaría poder sacarlos a ello hacer algo diferente.
Bueno, este proyecto es bueno, pero también no se olviden que aquí en donde vivimos también necesitamos que inviertan en mejorar la comunidad directamente por donde vivimos.
When people are able to clear their minds and just breathe, fresh air, it helps you feel better about everything.
I don't think it would affect me negatively in anyway.
Good idea. I'm glad our Mayor wants to do good things.
Rafael
Rafel
Rafel
Rafael
Rafael
Public transportation reduces car reliance.
I think the most positive affect would be being able to have a good time.
My biggest fear is safety because of location and the lack of or shortage of public safety in our city
Security, making sure the young kids are supervised so that they don't trash it. Making sure people take good care of the space.
I hope it's a good thing for Cleveland, for us.
yes because it will help the younger kids
no because itwill help the younger kids grow
yes i would
it just going to be good for kids my age and more
It will give me a safe place to calm and relax myself
It will effect me in a positive way
If it's a safe and positive space
There's nothing else I agree with every thing I submitted
yes
being able to go downtown to see the lakefront
happiness
no it won't
I like it
It would bring people together
more connections to family , friends , and relaxation
I live in Cleveland
I want to have a good well-being .
like being nice
people being mean and doin dumb stuff
my family n it would make me a lil bit happier
no this project will not effect me this will probably bring me and my family together cause there is somewhere fun for us to to go.
I'm not sure
It will make me feel happy ,safe fine
my safety
I wish I can go there it looks fun
Not addressing the issues crippling our communities now. We need more than a space to think, gather and party. We need help and relief, to feel safe, to have stable and affordable housing, to make a living wage to meet our basic needs!
It being positioned or properly prioritized, maybe in stages over time so that other needs can be addressed more efficiently and effectively.
I likes to fee for free and co outside
i love to more project
basketball
i not to say
More diversity , happy to see more people come together
Not feeling safe enough , mostly worried about the foundation , structure of new innovations
Be able to go down to lakeshore ad spend time with his daughter, go fishing, go feed birds with his daughter.
There was a point that Mr.Brown made about safety , he brought up the point of the foundation of the ground, would the land be able to uphold all the construction planned to happen and this makes him a little weary,
This projects feels more like a service Mr Brown said , there is a lack of diversity he kept emphasizing, he feels as if this is untrue just using the people as devices
See more people like - POC
He feel as if it wouldn't affect him at all. Mr Marvin says "they are going to do what they want to do , they are just getting the quota they need" They will do as they please
Think its a trick for tax payer to pay for the project , he also said something interesting that the history of the lakeshore is not welcoming , some black people - older - feel as if they are not allowed - due to past harm done to black people in Cleveland by non POC's
It's a better life style of living, working, a safe environment. Growth in economic development and a opportunities for all of to come together in our neighborhoods.
Thinking of all of the opportunity that it will bring our city to thrive on what it can do for investment within all communities
Future is our challenges and changes in orde to have better you have to see the vision and have a positive outcome to become the change 😊
I agree to growth investments opportunities for all and a vision that will serve everyone
I enjoy visiting local parks and Lake Erie. Helps me feel relaxed.
For Crystal It would be nice for them to visit , take visiting family members, thoughtful to do and to see the project finally go into affect
Safety may be a worry for Crystal
Crystal would be looking forward to holiday events , social events and for the project to follow through
Younger people are becoming more tolerant , they would feel as if they could take care of those who matte rot them better - taking people to visit the lakefront who are visiting family, safety could be good if the right regulation is are implemented , can gain a free mind , new opportunities for people may appear for those who are more in need more resources
A place to go
Safety needs to be in place
No
A place to have fun
Not enough security
Family and if presented opportunities economically and spend time with my family , good food and good laugh and play
people are displaced , no economic impact
Safe environment , child friendly environment
I don't know how effective it will be , whether or not they are frequently visiting , what if it is not catering to family enough , if it is not oriented in that way then there will be reason to go .
No closing thoughts
We are talking right now about security, you don't understand and it is going to be something economical for the State as well as for many people who are arriving here in Cleveland.
What my words were heard
I would like it to have twice as much security as what they are going to install in order to take better care of the elderly who are the most abused and the small children whose parents neglect them as well. Add security cameras so they don't know what is going to happen. a comfortable and quiet place
Tener donde llevar a la familia para pasar tiempo de calidad juntos y alejar a los niños de la tecnología y los videojuegos
Más espacios gratuitos Amplio espacios para parqueos
Esperamos que este proyecto se pueda lograr para la comunidad en general
Impactaria pisitivamente ya que habría más lugares de recreación
No me afecta negativamente, al contrario es positivo para mi familia y para mi
Valdría la pena totalmente
What are our priorities? An improvement of a tiny sliver of lakefront should be secondary to Gerentine. Clean lead-free water to a Cleveland residents.
This project might be more worth it to me if it included an offshore wind farm, so that the city may gradually, we need self off of fossil fuels and become energy independent.
Using precious resources to build things that required new pipes, makes me feel uneasy when I know that most of the children in the Brooklyn Centre neighborhood (who have been tested) have tested positive for lead.
Climate change migration hasn't even begun yet. During the next decade, millions of people will relocate to the Great Lakes region of North America for access to fresh water. The demand for green energy is rising, and Cleveland must take steps immediately to become energy independent. This includes all-electric buses, all-electric fire trucks, etc.
More family things to do for the children , Cleveland being a place to raise families
No negative - no construction - no growth of a city
Adequate funding
Maggie is pretty optimistic about the project but says IF the project goes through
Hope the project works and go through - hope it is supported rightfully
Will simply give something positive to do with family and friends.
I would just like to see free parking. Maybe a bar area and good food. Including vegan/ vegetarian.
Help the community
This project will positively affect me because it will provide a new space for me to enjoy in my city.
The project will be worth it to me if it's a family-friendly place with easy access & affordable parking.
I don't think the Lakefront project will directly affect my life, however it may improve my outlook on my City.
As a community together we can keep it clean, safe and more accessible for people of all ages
No negativity at all
Being able to be more involved and how to be more involved. Maybe just more information
As a community together we can keep it clean, safe and more accessible for people of all ages
I'm excited to see what is to come. I really would like to be involved in any way that I am able to. It brings joy to see the city grow and the community working together for a better everything.
Would change things make it a little different so people could connect as neighbors and as friends in our community
Having more trees and plants to make the air quality a little bit better
Everything would get a lot better as long as we replant trees where we take them from commute for people would be a lot better
Anything that's going to better our community it's gonna be good for our community, people, places and things
I don't think this project would impact positively or negatively. It wouldn't cause any major changes for me. I am OK either way.
If it actually happens
I just feel it would be a good place for people to come together and just have a good time.
I think having good security there is going to be very important for people to feel safe because it's downtown.
The water is dirty and polluted here so some TLC wouldn't kill us.
There is no need to try and make money off of a project like this if it's truly for THE PEOPLE.
Clean up the area and it will improve the water, soil and air quality and circulation — that's how you create a happy general public, not by creating more for-profit programs.
My only concern is the poor air quality here and the weak man made infrastructure, which is defiling the lakefronts.
Everything is not a money grab. Clean and tidy the place up and more good things will present itself to the community.
Being able to connect to the West side more , looking fo rewards to more events and programs , to network and for more opportunities
Forgotten communities id their biggest opposition
More opportunities for al people and to unify- more events and fun things to do for Clevelander
Neutral excitement about the project but feels for the forgotten communities , what is it doing for the east versus the west , they feel as its promoting people to come to the west side but there is no promotion for th east side , its one sided still but feels highly about the art scene as pertaining to resources - networking
Thinking about the experience of Cleveland , the better of Cleveland n Jazze has high hopes they said they do have some worries but believe if the right things are put in place and taken care of then the result should be positive if things and communities are not forgotten
More opportunities to grow with the community safely.
It's a good thing to be provided a space to think and get away from the pressures of your surroundings.
I don't think there's really any way for that
I don't think there's any direct negatives from building it
The only thing it could really do is provide jobs and safe recreation if handled correctly which can do a lot don't get me wrong but that's dependent on the community's willingness to interact with it that way.
Do it
Get to experience nature and people
Worried political things may get in the way for the people demographics, losing the natural beauty
Being able to experience Cleveland more , more universal events happening
I'm not from Cleveland's but have been going to school for the past 4 years I would love to come back and be able to visit the lakefront as a attraction and see the progression of Cleveland as well as businesses.
Want this project to be for the people , like Coventry , where the parking is free
It's nice to be more in touch with nature especially water sources
It may give another safe place to explore , free to go by myself or with others
Once it becomes bigger more people will come meaning maybe more danger if the right resources are not in place
Fun things and free parking
Some questions don't make sense to the project
No closing thoughts
No, not really.
It's good for walking around the lake.
Is good to have something to do and go
Change my schedule
I feel like this project would be really nice. I believe it would have a great effect on the city.
I could see there being some thing with flowers around and even a pool.
I believe you to bring some fun to city. As the people that have built this city, we should have some thing that we can enjoy. I want to see our city improve.
Cuando algo es positivo para la salud mental, ayuda en todas las areas de tu vida.
Yo creo que este proyecto valdría más la pena sí, toman en consideración la gente pobre.
Que no se olviden de brindarle oportunidades a la gente como yo que queremos trabajar, pero no sabemos mucho inglés, pero que nos gustaría trabajar en esos lugares así.
En lo personal es un proyecto que me ayudaría a desestresarme cuando lo necesite.
Espacios más amplios para parqueos Mejor acceso al proyecto
Siento que mis pensamientos están siendo escuchados
Creo que se necesitan más proyectos de esta naturaleza, que permitan la unidad de la comunidad
Si porque puedo tener un lugar más rápido donde poder ir
Crear más proyectos de deporte Actividades gratuitas
Pienso que deben hacer más proyectos deportivos en la ciudad.
It may become a thing I can enjoy to myself getting out seeing people and their life and experiencing the ways of the city
If there is no true diversity and not just black and white all people
Opportunity to earn life gains and financial gains
Not really , just hope the needs of the people are meet
I just hope to see this fall through rightfully
Connected to the community , and finding ways to expand
destroying historical land and not preserving it , building it back up , what if the project goes through but stops half way through and not the city will be at a disturbance
Knowing that the project is respecting all people
Most things are common , more opportune to hang with frenzies network at programs , maybe get a bigger art scene down over there, , to volunteer , go out and experience Cleveland
No closing thoughts

Recommendations

Themes from our discussions with credible messengers, community, and government

Residents, local nonprofits, and the city planners met last month to review all the data and develop recommendations about how to adapt the project to improve equity and wellbeing. Here are our recommendations for changes to this project:

1. Focus on safety without adding more police presence

icon arrow

Residents expressed many concerns around safety, and wanted to explore ways to approach resident safety that makes people feel comfortable visiting the community center without feeling targeted by security or police. We recommend that the city:

  • Collaborates with residents to create park guidelines/rules.
  • Establishes a site cleanup committee and safety Ambassador model to approach safety in a way that makes people feel comfortable without feeling targeted by the security/police presence.

2. Connect the project to broader neighborhood investments

icon arrow

Concerns about belonging led to insights on how we could pair investments at this site with investments across the neighborhood so everyone in the community benefits. We recommend that the city:

  • Create jobs for local residents to work on construction and offer amenities at this site.
  • Make broader investments in the St. Johns neighborhood — people want to see a greater commitment and investment in this part of the city that has been neglected in the past.
  • Be transparent about financial impacts and accessibility of the site when sharing plans with the community.

3. Ensure the community center is affordable, accessible, and relatable

icon arrow

Residents expressed concern that they would not be able to visit the community center because it won’t be affordable — both the admission itself, as well as surrounding amenities like parking or vendors. We recommend that the city:

  • Keep as many activities as possible free or low-cost so the entire community can participate
  • Incorporate wheelchair accessibility and different modes of transportation access, which is essential for residents.
  • Bring people together across differences through cultural art + language installations, signage, and display about of our shared history.

4. Invest in authentic communications with residents about what is happening

icon arrow

Residents expressed significant distrust about how the money will be used and if the project will ever be completed. We recommend that the city:

  • Communicates regularly about project updates and what is happening with residents’ input.
  • Develops innovative ways to reach all community members — such as engaging councilpersons to communicate about the project, hosting field trips to the site, recruiting more residents under 18 to advisory boards, and promoting the website.

What do you think?

Are these the right recommendations and next steps for the city? We would love to hear your input.

  • What did we get right?
  • Would you change or elaborate on any of the ideas here?
  • Is anything missing from this list?

Send us your ideas. We’d love to hear from you!